2016/12/15

Snyder, S. 2016, A Practical Approach for Increasing Students’ In-Class Questions

Prompts to Elevate Students’ Questioning Skills

Level One

  • Contextuals
    • How was X (event, text, work, etc.) shaped by its time?
    • Where did X originate and why?
    • Who was the originator of X and what was he or she like?
  • Definitions and clarifications
    • How do you define X (word, term, idea, etc.)?
    • What does this passage, concept, etc., mean?
    • What would be a specific, concrete example of X?
  • Analyzers
    • What parts or features make up the whole and what does each part do? How do the parts contribute to the whole?
    • How is X organized and why is it organized this way?

Level Two

  • Comparatives
    • How is X the same as that?
    • How is X different than that?
    • How are these more or less similar?
    • What is the opposite of X?
  • Causals
    • What factors caused X to happen?
    • Which of these factors is sufficient? Which contributing or probable? On what grounds can we eliminate possible causes or explanations?
  • Evaluatives
    • What are the most important features of X?
    • Why do you like or dislike X (or agree or disagree with this)? How strong is the case that X is correct?
    • What criteria are best for judging X?
    • What is the best order or priority for these things and why? What is the strongest argument against X?

Level Three

  • Counterfactuals
    • How would X change if this happened?
    • How would things be different if X had not happened?
    • How would things be different if X happened to a greater (or lesser) degree? 
  • Extenders (Synthesizers)
    • How can we apply X to this set of circumstances?
    • What can we predict if X is correct?
    • What ideas should be added to X?
    • What might happen if you added this to X?